For Teachers: Activities and Lesson Plans: Language Arts 7-12:
Lesson 1: Weighing the Risks: Would You Have Been an Abolitionist?

Language Arts:  Grades 9-10
Viewing and Interpreting Media, Writing, Discussing

Context and Content Knowledge

The activities involved with this lesson could be effectively taught over a three-day period for 45-minute classes, or one to two days of 90-minute block scheduling.

Long before the Civil War, attitudes about slavery divided the North and South.  Even in the North, being an abolitionist was not popular.   The students will view a segment of Safe Harbor, which will provide a media-oriented introduction to the concept of the anti-slavery movement in Northwestern Pennsylvania during the 1800’s.  Viewing the documentary and online transcripts will allow the students to begin thinking about the benefits and consequences of becoming an abolitionist; further, it will provide a foundation for the information that can be accessed in this interactive teacher guide.  Students will be able to read biographical information about people such as John Brown, Hamilton Waters, Cynthia Catlin Miller, The Vosburghs and William Himrod.  They will be able to compare and contrast newspaper articles that carry opposing views.  The teacher will provide questions for the students to consider as they prepare a two-part writing assignment (as outlined in Activities/Procedures below).

Rationale

In viewing the documentary and examining the resources available on the Safe Harbor web site and other linked resources, students will gain valuable information so that they may understand the various perspectives of the abolitionist movement.  The implications for such a learning experience are multi-faceted and far-reaching; students can explore the historical facts and gather knowledge about the context of slavery, and, at the same time, they will be utilizing higher-order thinking skills to interpret the underlying meanings and roots of many racial prejudices.  The writing assignment will both sharpen the students’ verbal skills and allow the students to examine their own opinions.  This activity will touch upon the importance of empathetic thinking, as well as inform the students of important historical information.

Standards

Learning to Read Independently 1.1.8.A, B, D, E, G, H
Reading Critically in All Content Areas   1.2.8.A, B
Types of Writing   1.4.8.B, C
Quality of Writing 1.5.8.A, B, C, D
Speaking and Listening  1.6.8.A, C, D, E, F
Research    1.8.8.B, C
*taken from the Academic Standards for Reading, Writing, Speaking, and Listening, as established by the Pennsylvania Department of Education      

Educational Goals     (what/how will students learn?)

  1. Students will view a segment of Safe Harbor and recognize the diverse perspectives of Northerners living during the 1800’s.
  2. Students will access biographical and historical information from a variety of web sites and further develop their understanding of the abolitionist movement.
  3. Students will write a reflective response to the documentary (specific subject and writing prompt can be developed by the individual teacher).
  4. Students will write an opinion piece detailing their own observations of racial prejudice and discussing whether or not they would have been willing to assume the risks of harboring and helping fugitive slaves.
  5. Students will engage in a group discussion in which they can share their writing assignments and evaluate the information on the documentary and on the website.

Activities/Procedures

  • Prefatory discussion by instructor explaining the content and purpose of the documentary
  • Students will view a short segment from the documentary, followed by a brief period for discussion
  • Students will have the opportunity to access the Safe Harbor web site and linked resources in order to gain more information about the people involved with the abolitionist movement in Northwestern Pennsylvania
  • Students will be given time to compose their thoughts on the documentary and to write an opinion piece about their perspective on the abolitionist movement
  • Students will be given time to discuss the issues of racial prejudice, especially as it pertains to history and its extensions into the present

Materials/References Needed

Safe Harbor documentary and DVD
Online transcripts of Safe Harbor interviews
Computers with internet access
http://www.wqln.org/safeharbor

Online Resources

Lesson plans developed by Emily Johnson, a 10th grade language arts teacher in Dubois, Pennsylvania.